Filmscanners mailing list archive (email@example.com)
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
filmscanners: Scanning Mechanisms
At 02:43 AM 7/21/01 -0700, Art wrote:
>Moving the film via a carrier, which is likely molded plastic, with
>plastic gearing, and also having it need to "mesh' with the motorized
>transport, and being that the carrier is prone to dust and dirt
>attraction and "the elements", makes it much harder to maintain
>integrity of precision movement.
Clearly the film has to be in SOME kind of carrier,
whatever the scanner brand. Austin's Leaf uses
aluminum carriers (Beseler) but all the scanners
I've owned have plastic-molded film holders of
varying complexity. Frankly, I feel a bit more
comfortable with my negatives up against plastic
than against metal.
There are hybrid schemes that work very well, such as
the older SprintScans. For all my griping about those
old SprintScans, they do have a very elegant and
well-executed scanning mechanism and optical bench.
The older SprintScans used a flimsy plastic film
holder, but quite adequate for the purpose. The
film holder clicks firmly into place onto a moveable
carrier, on precision linear slides (stainless steel,)
within the scanner. The film moves, during scanning,
and with great precision -- even though it's in a flimsy
The disadvantage of this scheme is that it does not
support batch-scanning at all. The scanner has no
way to advance to the next image -- that has to
be done by moving the plastic film holder by hand.