VueScan is very interesting and useful to the subscribers on this group, and
the program is somewhat opaque resulting in the many discussions of what
appear to be insignificant details and changes in the different versions. I
would venture to say that Vuescan is the primary scanning program used
though I have no statistics on which to base that.
Concerning the CMYK values for skintones, your guidelines appear to be more
or less correct. I have found Dan Margulis's guidelines to be a bit better
and empirically more accurate. He maintains that, for Caucasians, cyan
should be about 1/5 to 1/3 of magenta (Professional Photoshop 5) rather than
1/2 as you suggest.
Another problem that comes to mind is that scanners export the image in RGB
and desktop printers (without exceptions that I am aware of) require RGB
input, performing the RGB-CMYK conversion internally. As there is loss in
color in the RGB-CMYK conversion and the subsequent CMYK-RGB re-conversion
many try to avoid having to color-correct in CMYK despite the benefits of
the black channel.
----- Original Message -----
From: "Mikael Risedal" <firstname.lastname@example.org>
Sent: Saturday, March 31, 2001 11:24 AM
Subject: filmscanners: negative and skin tones
| To the scanner group.
| As a photographer Im "little bit tired "of reading about ( VueScan nr
| xxxx ) and i hoped to learn something from other people in the group,
| can be more interesting and useful.
| Therefor i begin with a small tip:
| To some of you who all ready know it- come with a another tip !
| Scanning negative film and skin tones are sometimes a tuff job. You have
| nothing to compare against, (as with a slide.)
| Faces and skin tones become often to red in printing, A good rule is to
| measure the face skin tone in a CMYK profile known for printing purpose.
| (do it in Photoshop 5.0 6.0)
| If you make corrections and have
| C about half of magenta
| M less then Yellow
| Y more then magenta + 5-10 %
| K -
| This figures give you a more natural skin tone in printing , and the red
| ugly are goon.
| Another good rule to know is that
| Grey in CMYK are about C= 32 M=20 Y0=20
| You can often estimate something in the picture who are grey.
| Mikael Risedal
| Get Your Private, Free E-mail from MSN Hotmail at http://www.hotmail.com.